User login

Who's online

There are currently 9 users and 39 guests online.

Online users

  • Just another voice
  • Sergei
  • Crenshaw Sepulveda
  • JulieM
  • Arts From The Heart
  • agathafrye
  • einmaleins
  • johnnycoke
  • wilson

Support OlyBlog

OlyBlog is run by volunteers who care about Olympia. If you like what we're doing, make a donation:

OlyBlog is powered by:

Who's new

  • dopenessmeter
  • CindyM
  • Arts From The Heart
  • patr
  • Peter Alden Stroble

Poster Calendar

July

    Creative Commons License
 
Submitted by Rick on Sun, 12/31/2006 - 9:55pm.

I noticed that Bayview has changed the sign in front of the store to include a reminder that they are a "locally owned" business. I assume this is evidence that Storeman's accountant is reporting that 2006 is not looking like such a great year. This got me to thinking about what it means to be "locally owned." What is the relationship between a business and the community? What can a business ask for based on this relationship, and what can the community ask for?

First, the point of contention: refusal to stock Plan B, a form of emergency contraception. I think there is no dispute that Storeman looked into his own heart, and made a decision that it was wrong, based on his religious beliefs. I'm pretty sure he didn't come under any pressure from the community to not stock Plan B -- it was his idea, and his idea alone.

I think it's fair to say that the response to this in Olympia has been negative, in a word. There have been well organized, and well populated demonstrations against this policy since the summer, and even the counterprotesters focused primarily on Storeman's right to not stock Plan B, not on Plan B per se (although I know of one person who did demonstrate against Plan B itself, and he demonstrated a not too firm grip on human biology with respect to reproduction when I pressed him on it).

So now, when it's starting to hurt the bottom line, we see the appeal: "We're locally owned." The message is clear: "You should shop here because we're better than Safeway or Top Food, who will just ship your dollars out of state." But, this brings up the question, are they really all that different? Bayview certainly isn't listening to the local voices calling for access to emergency birth control. That doesn't seem very invested in the local community.

The point that really struck me after seeing the new sign was that, Bayview receives certain advantages just from being in Olympia. For example, I'm sure people talked it up as a cool place to shop (as I know I did before the boycott). Storeman's benefits from that. And if, say, the City of Olympia included Bayview as an example of a successful local business, which they may do, for all I know, then Storeman's benefits. I'm sure Storeman's would welcome almost any kind of positive exposure that comes from being associated with Olympia, and accept it without a second thought.

This is beginning to sound like a one-way relationship, isn't it? What are the prospects that Storeman's would be willing to do some couples counseling (i.e., mediation with members of the community)? It seems like the right move, because right now, it looks like neither Storeman's or the community are getting their needs met by this relationship.

»

Interesting thoughts, Rick.

Interesting thoughts, Rick. I have often thought about this issue, since there are many local businesses I support with my dollars though I don't particularly agree with their politics.

Usually I still support them, because I still think I can make a difference with a local business where I can track down the owner and talk to them, and where complaints aren't sent to corporate headquarters out of state or something. Also, at least I am helping to provide for the people in my community who own or work in the business.

Even Right-Wing Christians have to eat.For some reason I find yahoos to be more palatable when they are in my own backyard...is that backwards?

Anyway, I am boycotting Storeman's because I support the cause and there is an organized campaign around it. I've known they didn't carry Plan B there for several years, but it wasn't enough to stop me from shopping there without the campaign. I shop at many local businesses who have bad policies that I disagree with. I used to buy prescriptions, beer, and ice cream there, but 80% of my groceries come from the Oly Food Co-op anyway.

Folks should know that MegaFoods is locally owned as well. You won't see them boasting about it- they get plenty of business. I like the place better than Storeman's anyway. Its less stuffy.

Jade

»

Thriftway Plan B Situation

I am really curious about how significant of a financial impact the boycott has had on The Stormans' two Olympia Thriftways.

A tough situation; both sides claim adherence to moral imperative.

I see that there might be an elemental misunderstanding taking place. In my view, it seems that the Stormans misunderstand the difference between contraception (in this case an emergency contraceptive) and abortion. But I may be wrong. And if the Stormans won't talk about it, how will I know?

On the flip side, I have to ask myself, what is it about the Stormans' views might I be mis-understanding? To this question, right now, I can't come up with a reasonable answer. That is why dialogue is necessary.

In the Course of Events

»

locally owned implies neighborliness

This implies neighborly spirit to the operations; a willingness to participate in a dialogue about community practices. If my neighbor is doing something that I object to, I certainly hope that he is willing to talk with me about it, and perhaps come to some resolution or compromise!

In the Course of Events

»

Top Foods

doesn't ship your money out of state...they are part of Bellingham based Haggen Food & Pharmacy 

the local Thriftways still have a program that kicks back 1% to local non-profit groups, no other grocer in town does this.

»

It's true about top foods,

It's true about top foods, I've started taking my business to them instead of bayview when I need things the co-op doesn't have.
The 1% kickbacks at thriftways only work if you have a card for the particular organization you want the kickback to go to (ie the film society is signed up in their program) and you have the cashier swipe it. then 1% of your purchase goes to that group.
The co-op has a policy where it gives away all profit (money that it didn't budget as part of operations) at the end of each year. Few people know about this. he year I was on the board we gave away $11,000, split between 6 organizations. I know there are years when it's been more than that. They also have a separate section of their budget for donations, and there are many community groups that receive a one-time (or monthly) donation of food from the co-op, such as safeplace.
»

This topic has been very much on my mind lately

Thank you, Rick, for your thoughtful comments.  At our last Plan B Oly planning meeting we had a visitor who expressed concern that the boycott was placing a locally owned business at risk.  Many of the boycott organizers are former Ralph's/Bayview shoppers because we believe in shopping locally.  However, as Evergreen labor studies instructor Sarah Ryan told me when I interviewed her for an in-depth article about just this issue in the January 2006 issue of Works In Progress (now available at Otto's, the Voyeur, Media Island, the Co-op, and many other places, or read it online here:
http://www.olywip.org/wip/node/449), we wouldn't want to support a store that breached community standards just because it is locally owned.  The fact that Ralph's/Bayview are locally owned is actually an especially good reason TO boycott -- individuals can have more impact on a smaller, locally owned store than on a national chain. 

I certainly agree that it's too bad the Stormans are unwilling to even discuss possible resolutions with boycott organizers.  We have made three attempts to initiate discussions with them, and they steadfastly refuse to engage in a dialogue with us.  It's mystifying when you consider that they claim to be eager to serve their community -- shouldn't they be more responsive to the concerns of long-term shoppers in the community?
»

Responsiveness to Community Values

It's really too bad that this issue has become divisive. I think we would benefit from a historical examination of anti-choice rhetoric. Unfortunately, this is about choice. I am assuming (correctly? - incorrectly?) that the Stormans' refusal to stock Plan B is because of his (their) belief that Plan B is an abortive measure - which it is not. There is a difference between abortion and contraception - which is what plan b is.

I am really encouraged to see so many in the community standing up for values and sticking with this boycott. Women have a right to choose. Women have a right to choose about what types of contraception to use. Women have a right to choose about abortion as well.

In the Course of Events

»

yes!

"we wouldn't want to support a store that breached community standards just because it is locally owned."

That is precisely it!

"Anybody who doesn't know that politics is crime has got a few screws loose."

»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

OlyBlog.net

OlyBlog is devoted to hyperlocal news and discussion specifically about Olympia, Washington. Contributors to OlyBlog are citizen journalists who care about their community and are tired of corporate media.

If you'd like to contribute, please register for an account. Here is a list of local news beats that need to be covered. You can post your news as a personal blog entry, and it will be reviewed (and possibly edited) for promotion to the front page. You can also send news via email. All members of OlyBlog agree to abide by our Social Contract. You should also look at our comment and fair use policies. If you are frustrated about something said in a comment thread, go here.

Docents are fellow citizen journalists who volunteer to be at your service in order to help with any blog-related issues. They are:

Rob Richards
Interests: community building; participatory art, democracy and economics; local politics; citizen journalism.

emmettoconnell
Interests: City Council, developing a local issues forum.

enpen
Interests: OlyBlog poster calendar, Olympia public art, local artist interviews, his family, poetry and stuff.

Robert Whitlock
Interests: peace, justice, nature, nonviolence, media, environment

Rick
Interests: citizen journalism, hyperlocal media, the knowledge commons.

Get Firefox!

OlyBlog is a site for news and discussion about Olympia, Washington.
free hit counter