User login

Who's online

There are currently 3 users and 27 guests online.

Online users

  • Guglielmo
  • oldtimeydave
  • Josopler

Support OlyBlog

OlyBlog is run by volunteers who care about Olympia. If you like what we're doing, make a donation:

OlyBlog is powered by:

Who's new

  • Josopler
  • jasonla
  • Jododp
  • Jfodfie
  • GregDiablo

    Creative Commons License
 
Submitted by redrhythmicmoon on Wed, 11/14/2007 - 9:24am.

Media reports of the Olympia port protests would have us believe that the protesters are a marginalized, but organized, few. That is not the case. People who oppose the war are in the vast majority, and our supposed leaders, such as Brian Baird, refuse to act in accordance with the will of their constituents.

When Baird refused to oppose the so-called "surge," he was not representing the will of Olympia residents. That is not democracy. The entire democratic party, elected in these past elections to put an end to this horrendous war, have not fulfilled their promises.

What are we left with when lawmakers disregard the demands of the people, when our democracy breaks down? What should people do when it's obvious that fascism, under the guise of democracy, has overtaken their government?

If we are living in a true democracy, the demonstrators at the port would not feel like they have to put their bodies on the line to let their lawmakers know they are serious about ending this war.

Baird, and others like him should be ashamed for not listening. He has created serious unrest at home as he bows to Bush in Washington.

As the war continues to perpetrate atrocity, and our news outlets tell skewed stories, people of conscience will continue to resist. I'm proud of these Olympians for contributing to the resistance to the war, and the corporate and elite interests that maintain it.

»

Scapegoat

Personal responsibility. Blaming it on others sounds juvenile.
»

Your second sentence is

Your second sentence is inaccurate. True, there are many, most likely the majority now, who oppose the war. But out of that it's a small percentage who feel it justifies lawbreaking or riotous behavior.

How did smashing US Bank's windows aid the peace effort?

Please give me a second grace. Please give me a second face. I've fallen far down, the first time around, now I just sit on the ground in your way.
Nick Drake

»

Lame.  Blaming Baird for

Lame.  Blaming Baird for what happened last night does not absolve you of anything.  In fact, it makes you sound like a whiner.  Own up, own up.

I guess the headline should read: "Baird Breaks Windows at US Bank"

Is this your attempt at moving the PR machine in the favor of protestors?  You've lost the PR battle, long ago, I'm afraid.

»

I really

don't care what you have to say, Norm
»

I'm just trying to help you out

As a friend of mine is fond of saying, "If you aren't ashamed of it, Own it!".

»

Then we can agree on

Then we can agree on something.

»

When someone says "My voice

When someone says "My voice is all that counts, the rest of you can go to Hell" they're not going to find much support or common ground.

Please give me a second grace. Please give me a second face. I've fallen far down, the first time around, now I just sit on the ground in your way.
Nick Drake

»

Is this a school yard?

You guys sound like a bunch of bullies.

If you want to hear things that only validate your narrow understanding of what's happening, go watch Fox News.

It is not your responsibility to express your opinion at every possible opportunity. I think we're pretty clear about how you feel. Let someone else have the floor for a minute, especially if it results in a fruitful discussion, instead of getting in everyone's face. Geeze.


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

We're narrow?  That's

We're narrow?  That's funny.  All the fruit is spoiled, Rick.  But, I'll heed your advice and shutup now.
»

It's Pretty Much Come To That On This Topic

The right to be heard seems pretty one sided and those being against the protesters here are being bullied every time they just want their voices heard too.

I don't need my opinion validated and it's not up to you to determine whether or not it's narrow.  I have every right to believe and state that I believe those who destroy public & private property under the guise of stopping a war are the narrow minded ones. 

"Do not mistake for conspiracy and intrigue what can best be explained by stupidity and incompetence." - Unknown

»

Everyone has the right...

...to be heard. Including the person who made the original post. No one tried to engage him/her to open a conversation. They just started barking and spitting. We've had several specific requests from new posters that they not be immediately attacked when the put an idea out there. And that's exactly what happened here. And you're supporting the shutting down of this conversation. You're censoring open communication. Norm, EG, and Merwyn had all had many opportunities to say their piece on this topic.

Saying something interesting can be probing or supportive, it's not just about agreeing. There are a lot of ways to go with it. But "lame" is not a useful contribution and I'm disappointed that you would try to defend it.


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

Rick

I disagreed with the misplaced blame. I'm not sure why that has you in a tizzy, but it must make sense to you. Considering this person came over to my thread and shared their opinion, it doesn't seem like it should be out of bounds for me to do the same.
»

Really Rick. Agree, or

Really Rick. Agree, or disagree, we'll all get over that soon enough. But "narrow"?

You're right to remind us to keep our own threads and limit comments to something constructive, but that goes both ways, right?

Please give me a second grace. Please give me a second face. I've fallen far down, the first time around, now I just sit on the ground in your way.
Nick Drake

»

I'm so bored of the "lame" crap.

Say something interesting or don't say anything.

The person made a very interesting point that really no politician has shown a leadership role here. If y'all would stop throwing spitballs long enough to listen, there might be a conversation there. Does it make sense now, Norm?


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

I didn't claim anyone was lame

Interesting conversation? Possibly. I think it's wrong to place blame outside of your own person/organization. If you think it's right to protest, go for it, don't blame the fact that you are protesting on others though. Really you could place the blame on all kinds of things, but ultimately it was the protestors decision to go down to the port, nobody forced their hand.
»

But, Norm...

...if you're half way down someone's throat, how are you gonna have a conversation?


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

Rick

Really how am I down anyone's throat? I posted a simple, like two sentence comment. I think it's important that people take ownership of their behavior. That is ALL that I said. I didn't tell him he was wrong, I didn't say his idea was off, I just mentioned that it's silly to pass the blame onto another party. I'm sorry you didn't like that, but I hardly feel it's worthy of being down anyone's throat. I think you are overreacting here.
»

Don't ask me...

...look at the response you got.


> Say something interesting or say nothing at all. <
»

Gee Rick

you think that may be because it touched a nerve by making sense? You should go read OperaGirl's post in another thread. It pertains to how she deals with her boys when they start pointing fingers.
»

Nice logic, man

You'll go far with those leadership skills.


> Say something interesting or say nothing at all. <
»

Nice defense

you'll go far with those people skills.
»

I know you are...

...but what am I?


> Say something interesting or say nothing at all. <
»

A sphincters says, "What"?

=P

I still owe you a beer btw. IF you ever show up at the broho again. I haven't been able to actually sit and talk with you after watching, "Sicko".

»

Cool.

I'd like to have that conversation.


> Say something interesting or say nothing at all. <
»

Can't be much worse

Than other leadership skills I've seen.  "Call me" indeed.
»

Lame Crap

I assume this was for me, so I'll respond.  Rick, you're not going to like everything posted here.  Is it yours or ours?  When I see the broad brush applied equally I'll act in kind, but until then I'm entitled to my opinion and will voice it freely.  Non-violently, of course.

If you can't handle a comment in dissent remove the comment.

»

"Lame"...

...is not an opinion, it's a distraction.


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

Why don't you stop telling people what to do.

Talk about a closed off world view! That would be an apt description of your recent behavior on this blog. I am not sure what makes you think it is ok to tell people what to say, or how to say it out side of profanity. C.

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Why don't you say something worth reading...

...otherwise you're just wasting our time.


When you think of the long and gloomy history of man, you will find more hideous crimes have been committed in the name of obedience than have ever been committed in the name of rebellion. -C.P. Snow
»

Do you think that giving

Do you think that giving attention to the posts that you find to be a waste of your time, helps, or hinders the goal? Just curious.
»

Worth reading...

What is worth reading?  To some the Weekly World News chock full of information on Elvis sightings and the Loch Ness Monster is worth reading.  A diverse community will have diverse views and opinions.  I thought you were all for empowering people to engage in a community media?  (How many more liberal buzzwords could I have got in there?)
»

Huh?

"I am not sure what makes you think it is ok to tell people what to say, or how to say it out side of profanity." For most people, myself included, civility is not simply the absence of profanity. If I witness someone being uncivil to an old man, I intrude. If I read something uncivil here, I may intrude. I think it's "ok" to do so because I place a high value on civility and the atmosphere of Olyblog. If you think of Olyblog as a home in which you are a guest, I think you have an obligation to behave well. And behaving well means more than just not saying "shit."
»

That is funny...

Coming from someone who complains continually about the tone of everyone else’s posts. Rarely do you bother looking at the points someone makes, but rather you get worked into a lather because of their tone. Rick can choose to behave like an adult or say things like 'why don't you post something worth reading'. It is up to him. So far, anyone who defies his world view and does so with out apology is treated like they don't count. It is typical of the liberal left to work at avoiding the subject and just whine about tone, and feelings, and so on, rather than just deal with the issue. Fortunately any clear thinking person can see through the convolutions. C.

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Blame

IMHO each and all of us are to blame for the war and for how it plays out in our communities.. 

Even those who have most tried to stop the war in Irak could have, perhaps, somehow, done a better job of it in at least some one aspect of his or her work for peace. I know this applies to myself.

Those who are outright war-mongers, war-profiteers, killers, defenders of tyranny (e. g. the Olympia Police Department and D. A.'s office), counter-protesters, and those who make death threats in comments to Olympian news stories--these people obviously share a great burden of the blame. But they're victims, too--victims of detrimental, stunting causes and conditions from family upbringing, from inadequate education, from corporate media propaganda, from the lies the've been spoon-fed with from Karl Rove, George Bush, Dick Cheney, and lest we forget, Gen. Colin Powell; etc.. So not only are these men and women deserving of our pity; they also deserve our compassion. 

Let's stop the war, inside and out.

See you soon on the barricades.

Out of Irak! Out of Our Ports!
»

You can still have compassion

You can still have compassion for someone while pointing out the effects of their actions. Sure, the world is a messed up place, I'm as much a product of it as anyone. We are all tools for a destructive system. However, can you say that our democracy is a functioning one right now? Baird has a responsibility to his constituents which he has not met. Demonstrators would not have a reason to be putting themselves in harms way if Baird was doing his job.
»

Disgusting

That's all I've got to say. Well, not really, there's more.

Not even the entirely correct forum, but the attitudes are here, as is the ignorance and utter incapability of reasoned thought.

Protesting the return of equipment from a war is idiotic at best. Great, don't like the war, the administration, pasta, whatever. That's what 2008 is for. I thought we were going to be out of Iraq after we elected this last batch. Wasn't that the premise many who won ran on? Are we admitting that the Democratic party did indeed dupe their constituents?

In any case, the hypocritical protesters are serving to do only one thing, which is to make sure that soldiers are receiving less training that will potentially save their lives when they go back, because their equipment is stuck in a port due to a handful of people that can't actually take a solid stand and say what they really believe. It is obvious to thosee that can take a bit broader view of what is going on to see that the protesters are directly affecting the lives of the soldiers who use this equipment. If you think going into combat is as simple as putting a gun into someones hand, you've been playing too much Halo. Every day this equipment sits somewhere unused for whatever reason, it's time taken away from the people that count on it for survival. Explain that away, please. I can't believe some actually placed flowers, with a knife behind their back.

The protesters might get some respect if they'd just stand up and say "we hate those who started and now manage this war, we hate the military, everyone in it, anyone who may profit or support it, and this is how we show it", but instead of potentially alienating a large percentage of the population who is also anti-war by showing their true beliefs, the protesters have instead chosen a different way of protesting, which on the surface doesn't seem quite so repugnant. Obviously the extremism can't be entirely contained, or destroying private property that has nothing to do with vehicles being offloaded in a port wouldn't happen.

I hope some that think they support this type of protest will take a moment to reflect on how getting soldiers killed is inline with your beliefs. If you can say "that's an acceptable consequence to my actions" then you've got my respect. Otherwise, you don't have a leg to stand on, because you clearly don't understand the repercussions of your actions on those who use this equipment. I expect the majority to fall in the latter category, because they wouldn't be protesting this way if they were capable of comprehending any of this.

»

Actually...

Having this discussion in this forum is less likely to affect actual PMR policy, since we organize openly and the place to have that discussion is in turn with the other people who are in the room, not online.

That said, we obviously disagree. The woman who brought her children to the Friday blockade (successful for 17 hours) specifically came BECAUSE we were blocking incoming vehicles and not directly endangering anyone who was in Iraq and needed them.

I actually voted against this policy myself, because it would have let me get better photographic documentation of the vehicles numbers and quantity, and derive the number of damaged vehicles. DOD would not tell us that kind of thing but we can see with our own eyes if we wish. Conflict makes that harder.

We voted 2/3 vs 1/3 for this policy (stopping all military use of P.O.O.) and I support that move now, since it involved many times more people (and many of them new) than the previous actions. It also got news of the resistance out to a wider section of the US. Gotta go now...

»

Re: MikeH's comment

"Protesting the return of equipment from a war is idiotic at best" 
 
You've obviously missed the whole point of the protests. They're about resisting militarization of the port.

"There's a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart, that you can't take part, you can't even passively take part, and you've got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels, upon the levers, upon all the apparatus, and you've got to make it stop! And you've got to indicate to the people who run it, to the people who own it, that unless you're free, the machine will be prevented from working at all!" - Mario Savio, leader of the Berkeley Free Speech Movement
»

I stopped reading at

"...ignorance and utter incapability of reasoned thought." Perhaps you should put that somewhere near the end of your screed the next time you want someone to actually read it.
»

Time to end the ping pong match fellas.

nt
»

Well,

"I stopped reading at"...

I'm surprised to see you could make it past the first word then.

It never ceases to amaze that those with closed minds are incapable of calmly or rationally discussing a topic. Kind of like the protestors in this case. Perhaps there is a reason these protests are effective, and why they should be held. But from what I've seen so far, it's about putting concrete on railroad tracks and breaking windows of private business. Hasn't done much to sway public opinion, at least not the way intended I'm sure.

Ping pong match would indicate that someone serves and the ball is returned.

Are we ending this on a Patriot Act note?

»

Are we ending this on a

Are we ending this on a Patriot Act note?

Errr, "God bless the USA!", is that what you were lookin for?

»

I would have read the whole thing

if you'd offered it respectufully. Don't take this wrong. I have no problem with you sharing your views. I'm an exceptionally open-minded fellow. I'm just sick and tired of rudeness these days.
»

Email speaks for itself

This email speaks for itself:

On Nov 12, 2007 12:50 AM, Sandy OlyPMR < email addres withheld to prevent censorship > wrote: Just to clarify -- These regularly scheduled events are NOT intended to replace the continuous presence down at the port entrance, still very much needed.

And, although for many of us tomorrow is a holiday from work, that is not the case for Evergreen students, who have to go to school. Evergreen students have been the primary presence at the port. Lets show them we appreciate their efforts by stepping in so they can devote some time to their school work.

-Sandy .........This email speaks for itself It’s up to you to write

Email President Evergreen.... purcel@evergreen.edu

Olympia Mayor Foutch.... mfoutch@ci.olympia.wa.us

Olympia Mayor elect.... dmah@ci.olympia.wa.us

Port Director Galligan.... edg@portolympia.com

»

Congressman Brian Baird

Congressman Baird's explicit support for the surge definitely factored in my decision to participate in civil resistance against the use of the port to enable an ongoing unlawful war of occupation.
»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

OlyBlog.net

OlyBlog is devoted to citizen journalism, including hyperlocal news and discussion specifically about Olympia, Washington. If you care about this community and are tired of corporate media, then this is the place for you.

If you'd like to contribute, please register for an account. Here is a list of local news beats that need to be covered. You can post your news as a personal blog entry, and it will be reviewed (and possibly edited) for promotion to the front page. Once you've established a record of responsible blogging, you can become an autonomous user. You can also send news via email. All members of OlyBlog agree to abide by our comment and fair use policies. If you are frustrated about something said in a comment thread, go here.

Now playing at:

Latest Classified Ads

Port of Olympia Action

Get Firefox!


More Flickr photos tagged with "olympia" and "washington"

OlyBlog is a site for news and discussion about Olympia, Washington.
free hit counter