User login

Who's online

There are currently 3 users and 47 guests online.

Online users

  • Marcie
  • agathafrye
  • wilson

Support OlyBlog

OlyBlog is run by volunteers who care about Olympia. If you like what we're doing, make a donation:

OlyBlog is powered by:

Who's new

  • LongRider
  • non illegitimi ...
  • acreatureapart
  • eristalis
  • Hillguy

    Creative Commons License
 
Submitted by chad360 on Tue, 02/12/2008 - 7:33am.

Hiya OlyBlog!

Al Gore (from "The Assault on Reason", p. 24), "Leadership means inspiring us to manage through our fears. Demagoguery means exploiting our fears for political gain."

Where is the US political scene? Leaning towards leadership or tending towards demagoguery?

Any thoughts?

I wish Al Gore was running for President, because I'd vote for him.

 

»

Here are some other interesting quotes that mesh in ways

"I do not believe in communism any more than you do,
but there is nothing wrong with the communists in this country.
Several of the best friends I have are Communists."
-- Franklin D. Roosevelt
(1882-1945), 32nd US President
Source: The New York Times, May 6th, 1933
http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quote_blog/Franklin.Roosevelt.Quote.1C5F


My mother's family thought that FDR was the devil incarnate and would not have been surprised to hear that several of his best friends were communists. I think they would have supported the scheme for a coup to get rid of FDR and seen that coup as a necessary evil, an important protection of the American way of life.

Almost all of them overcame their fear and hatred of FDR and drew the social security (and related Medicare) benefits that the Great Satan FDR established. Things change.

"I never would have agreed to the formulation of the
Central Intelligence Agency back in forty-seven,
if I had known it would become the American Gestapo."
-- Harry S. Truman
(1884-1972), 33rd US President
1961
http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quote_blog/Harry.Truman.Quote.B224

Truman beat my great uncle Roscoe to become senator of Missouri in 1935. Truman was sponsored by the corrupt Pendergast Kansas City democratic machine. Pendergast was prosecuted and convicted as I recall. Lots of folks never had anything more to do with him. He became a political leper. I believe that Truman as president took a day off to attend Pendergast's funeral and shrugged off any criticism of his loyalty and friendship with Pendergast. Truman had integrity and was remarkably gritty.

 

"The individual is handicapped by coming face to face
with a conspiracy so monstrous he cannot believe it exists.''
-- J. Edgar Hoover
Source: speaking of communism (1956)
http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quote_blog/J..Edgar.Hoover.Quote.4FB0

 

Hoover seems to me to look more and more like a demagogue as time goes by. All the tolerance demonstrated in the FDR quote above is missing in Hoover. The integrity and accountability of Truman (the buck stops here) are missing in Hoover imho. Yet, for all that, I think it could be argued that Hoover was certainly more influential and powerful than Truman and possibly more so than even FDR.

I think the sad truth is that demagoguery is a powerful political tool and it is difficult for folks to avoid wielding that power if they decide that the means justify the ends. For that reason, I think we should always stand up for means that our grandchildren will recognize as honorable. If our end goal is just, then our means must also be just. Demagogues use fear to erode support for just and honorable means. If there is any question about how that works in our world today, look at the discussion regarding torture and waterboarding as a means to make us safe. Our grandchildren will not be proud of this time. It will look like the Japanese internment in retrospect.

 

»

Thougtful response-

wow, what a great group of comments- >where did you get these clips? did you just have this stuff on hand?<

Well, I'm reading this Gore book, and it resonates. Tired of living under this oppressive cloud of "fear, uncertainty, & doubt", always being told to fear "terrorists", and the *insane* focus that the US has on national security.

Although, to be fair, even when the Dems were in, there was little change-

-maybe not outright war, but still little change as far as foreign policy.

 

»

Umm.

Living under a cloud of fear, uncertainty and doubt, it is easy to recall the Clinton administration, and even the recent change of control of congress. We were repeatedly attacked under the Clinton administration, and very little was done to stop them from happening. Terrorists blew up the garage of the WTC, and that with out doubt caused fear for the people of NY and much of the upper east coast. It caused uncertainty in the rest of the nation. 

We lived with the doubt of a liberal president and now a liberal congress who constantly shill and forward an agenda of class envy, which goes a long ways to creating doubt. The Bush administration is at fault also, but not as much as congress. 

I would think that this stuff is pretty obvious, and that the demagogry comes from the left. I don't believe it comes from the right, however that does not mean there are not problems. The right has created a vacuum of leadership for this nation, from the president on down through the congress. That is a problem in and of itself, but a knock on effect is that it allows the left to demagogry to rush to fill the vacuum. The candidacy of the "Breck Girl" is a perfect example of this. His entire run for the presidency was based on class envy, creating doubt and demagogy. His two Americas was his slogan and he did nothing to hide it. 

Lastly there was out right war, it was in Bosnia. Somalia was a small scale war to be sure, but it was war, and our failure to have any actual resolve back by strong leadership enabled the terrorists to gain strength. As far as change in foreign policy, I would suggest that actually taking the fight to the terrorists, defeating them one by one, eliminating their ability to become strong like they were in the beginning of this decade, is a radical change in policy. Wouldn't you agree? 


C. 

 

 

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in. 

Thomas Sowell

 

»

I subscribe to Liberty Quotes

get an email every day with two or three quotes.  I cut and paste the best or my favorites into a word doc. 
»

You get them from

from liberty-quotes.ca? 

 

I keep traveling around the bend/There was no beginning, there is no end/It wasn't born and never dies/There are no edges, there is no sides/Oh yeah, you just don't win/It's so far out - the way out is in-George Harrison

»

http://liberty-tree.ca/

nt
»

That's what I meant to type...

Too tired to type straight I see... 

 

I keep traveling around the bend/There was no beginning, there is no end/It wasn't born and never dies/There are no edges, there is no sides/Oh yeah, you just don't win/It's so far out - the way out is in-George Harrison

»

Another insipring speech from the rightists

to get out the fear vote. Yes indeed, vote for a Democrat and terrorists will attack us:

"...we are a nation at war. And Barack and Hillary have made their intentions clear regarding Iraq and the war on terror. They would retreat and declare defeat. And the consequence of that would be devastating. It would mean attacks on America, launched from safe havens that make Afghanistan under the Taliban look like child’s play. About this, I have no doubt... I would forestall the launch of a national campaign and make it more likely that Senator Clinton or Obama would win. And in this time of war, I simply cannot let my campaign, be a part of aiding a surrender to terror." --M. Romney.

...exploiting our fears for political gain. And it's only going to get worse between now and November.

»

Do you remember the...

Retreat and surrender in Somalia, and the effect it had on the terrorists like Bin Laden? It emboldened them. It fed their will and their resolve to think of us as a 'paper tiger'. So as you pretend that what the liberal left wants to do, to retreat and surrender, is something other than what it is, what do you think the knock on effect will be? When a sworn enemy of our nation and our way of life says that voting for liberal candidates should be what Americans do, isn't that a hint? What would it take for you to 'get it'?


C.  

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

You mean, the the retreat from Lebanon?

nt
»

That retreat too.

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

are you on topic?

My thread, my topic, your comments...if you are not on topic, post your questions on your own thread, OK?

Debate these questions you have with Gug on your 'blog...this space is for me and this question and the back-& forth that this question is generating, not another vehicle for your agenda (which you are welcome to have of course, just not here).

Gug posted a great example of right-wing demagoguery, and I'll leave it at that for now-

 

»

I responded to your comment and you didn't why?

Don't follow the topic and you have to leave, but good job Gug? Really? C'mon. C.

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Did you miss my Romney quote?

I think it's an excellent example of the fear-based demagoguery that this thread is about. If you want gold star too, you need come up with your own examples...and you don't even have stick to just the rightist demagogs.
»

Did you miss my response to your Romney quote?

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Honestly, I just see a lot of specualtion and opinion

I think we're looking for something more substancial here, like a good quotation to illustrate the demagoguery you speak of. Otherwise its just more party-line bluster.
»

Did I not mention the Breck Girl? Or are you just being...

Argumentitive?  

 

 

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Good Job Gug (yup that is what I said)

...and I do follow, did respond, and still think Gug's post(s) "rawk" and yours lacks substance, although we may even agree about what "leadership" is (regardless of if we disagree where we need to be lead).

The other posting are "spot on" and contribute...

...Counter-point: where is your example of "liberal" demagoguery?

Just curious if you have a great quote hanging out that you'd like to contribute?

»

Look at the link ....

HERE 

 

The candidacy of the "Breck Girl" is a perfect example of this. His entire run for the presidency was based on class envy, creating doubt and demagogy. His two Americas was his slogan and he did nothing to hide it.  

C.

 

P.S. How does a out of context quote from a Nazi fit with this discussion?  

 

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Sorry, but you should realize by now that

I just automaticially disregard comments containing characterizations like "Breck Girl." If you have some examples of Edward's fear-based demagoguery, please share.
»

Yes Gug, everything about his lying and his 2 America's.

http://www.mickwright.net/images/2007/02/edwards-home.jpg

The other America 

 

 Veterans under bridges and his $400.00 dollar hair cuts.

C.  

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

What does a financially successful man's home

or hair cut have to do with fear-based demagoguery? If you want to start a thread providing examples of the low quality of rightist political dialog, you go right ahead. It will be one of the longest threads on ever on Olyblog. In the mean time, I'm still waiting for some substance on this thread.
»

word, still waiting for...

...a quote or something to support your claim that demagoguery comes from the left/liberals...

>yawn<

...time for espresso! This time of year it seems that 10am is noon~

 

»

If you can't see the

If you can't see the demagogry of the Breck Girl's behaior, demanding other redistribute their wealth as he see fit while people are "sleeping under bridges" (clearly trying to create an emotional response to get the political gain he is after) what is the point of looking it up for you. It is a joke how utterly disingenuous you can be and how you convieniently refuse to acknowledge reality when it is as big as the nose on your face. What do I do with that except demonstrate your hypocrisy and let people see it for what it is. C. Funny my rich text function doesn't work now. I wonder how that happened?

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

I'm all Love today Tsch.

Nothing but "I words" until things calm down on Olyblog. I'm sorry you think me hypocritical. I am having some difficulty recognizing where Edwards is exploiting fear for political gain. Personally, I see nothing wrong with appealing to positive emotions. Maybe that's what makes me seem hypocritical to you. But I really don't see appealing to positive emotions, such as compassion, as a form of demagoguery. If that's hypocritical than I and my nose are really okay with that characterization. It's all good.

Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.! --John Maynard Keynes
»

Oh goodie!

Claiming that it is "positive" doesn't make it so. It just clarifies what I am talking about. If you are fine with it, great so am I! We seem to agree!

One of the great non sequiturs of the left is that, if the free market doesn't work perfectly, then it doesn't work at all-- and the government should step in.

Thomas Sowell

»

Correct indeed

There is no way for me to objectively determine if fear or compassion are positive or negative emotions. The relative merrits of policies that exploit either are purely a matter of my own subjective judgements. Abslutely!

Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.! --John Maynard Keynes
»

What I get is that this has nothing to do...

...with bin Laden. It has everything to do with control through fear. It was Goering who said it best:

Why of course the people don't want war. Why should some poor slob on a farm want to risk his life in a war when the best he can get out of it is to come back to his farm in one piece? Naturally the common people don't want war neither in Russia, nor in England, nor for that matter in Germany. That is understood. But, after all, it is the leaders of the country who determine the policy and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along, whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the peacemakers for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same in any country.

> It's OK to be nice. <
enpen's social contract
»

Thank you...

...great comment and super quote...I assumed you just had this on the ol'd desktop ready to send off?

The resourcefulness and quick posting on OlyBlog is really amazing me!

Regardless of viewpoint, the speed and resourcefulness is inspiring & cool.

»

from today's news...

So, another example of Leadership or Demagoguery?

"US Rejects Russian call for new space treaty"

I'm pretty much convinced that the current US admin (esp. the Exec.s) are not leaders.

»

Two Americas

Yes, this stuff is pretty obvious. Here's the research:

Household wealth in the United States experienced rapid growth during the past decade despite a recession and slow recovery after the stock market crash in 2000. According to Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) conducted by the Federal Reserve Bank, aggregate household net wealth nearly doubled from $25.9 trillion in 1995 to $50.1 trillion in 2004 in real 2004 dollars.1 How much did that rapid growth in wealth during the recent decade affect wealth distribution and has it increased inequality? Furthermore, what was the role of housing throughout this process? Those are the questions that this paper tries to answer.

The typical metaphor used to describe wealth or income growth is a rising tide lifting all the boats, but that image does not catch the true nature of rapid wealth growth. As low-income households have difficulty making ends meet and high-income households have better investment opportunities with reduced risks through more diversified financial holdings and access, wealth growth often means no growth at the lower end but huge growth at the top. Growing inequality in the distribution of household wealth consequently accompanies growing wealth over time. In fact, even if the rich and the poor experienced the same speed of growth, the absolute gap between the rich and poor would keep enlarging due to the difference in the size of the base.

From a longer historic perspective, economic and wealth growth in the United States during the postwar period has already produced growing inequality in this country. As Keister and Moller (2000) point out, while inequality of wealth was consistently more extreme throughout Europe for many decades, by the early 1990s, the United States had surpassed all industrial societies in the extent of inequality of household wealth.2 By 1997, one man, Bill Gates, was worth about as much as the 40 million American households at the bottom of the wealth distribution.3

Read the report (pdf).


> It's OK to be nice. <
enpen's social contract
»

The Strunk and White approach to Demagoguery by Guiliani

Omit needles words:

“America will be safer with a Republican president.”

Fear=political gain.

»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

OlyBlog.net

OlyBlog is devoted to citizen journalism, including hyperlocal news and discussion specifically about Olympia, Washington. If you care about this community and are tired of corporate media, then this is the place for you.

If you'd like to contribute, please register for an account. Here is a list of local news beats that need to be covered. You can post your news as a personal blog entry, and it will be reviewed (and possibly edited) for promotion to the front page. Once you've established a record of responsible blogging, you can become an autonomous user. You can also send news via email. All members of OlyBlog agree to abide by our comment and fair use policies. If you are frustrated about something said in a comment thread, go here.

Now playing at:

Get Firefox!


More Flickr photos tagged with "olympia" and "washington"

OlyBlog is a site for news and discussion about Olympia, Washington.
free hit counter