The world was flat and dry with 100+ degree heat as we cruised US-10 past Joshua Tree National Park on the last leg of our 24 hour marathon drive from Olympia to Phoenix. Last Tuesday, Media Island, in partnership with Students for a Democratic Society, sent a diverse group of Olympia activists to travel to Phoenix for Arizona Freedom Summer. Five of us, Yonatan, Angel, Leah, Johnny and I piled into the Media Island Van and took off praying that the old V8 didn't kick the dust. It nearly did- on several occasions- but we made it back to share with you all our experiences.
The convergence of folks came on the date of the enactment of Arizona law SB 1070, otherwise known by the Orwellian name “The Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act.” The original language of the law gave state law enforcement agencies the ability to enforce tougher standards on immigrants than the federal government. It also opened the door for probable racial profiling, ordering all local law enforcement agencies to ask to see the papers of anyone they suspect is an undocumented immigrant.
The law soared to national prominence as social justice groups pointed to it as a main reason why we need comprehensive immigration reform. The Obama administration back tracked on it's earlier statements to make that the “next big change” after healthcare reform. Placed permanently on the federal legislative back burner, right wing legislators within state government in Arizona took action with an offensive law, shifting the frame of national debate farther to the right.
Fear mongering corporate media outlets after the initial success of their wholly owned and constructed “Tea Party” took matters further in bringing back to life and prominence the militia movement with the so called “Minute Men.” These elementary school references to the mainstream version of US history bring a false warm and fuzzy feeling to what is effectively a bunch of white guys, racially motivated by reinforced media stereotypes of Latinos, who patrol together along the border with big guns and trucks. These middle aged children of the first person shooter video game generation seem to think it's fun and patriotic rounding up poor men and women who have traveled for days or weeks trying to make it here just so they can make minimum wage at the crappiest of jobs.
This is the back drop of the protests. We were cruising for a bruising in Sheriff Joe Arpaio country, the infamous sheriff who makes his inmates wear pink underwear and who deputizes volunteer sheriffs so he can go after immigrants in big raids. His jail was known for it's brutality with some being beaten and killed and the regular use of embarrassment tactics like the pink underwear and long sentences for relatively minor crimes. Sheriff Joe brags about his raids on businesses employing undocumented immigrants and about doing the job of federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. His raids of homes and border patrols have rounded up over 40,000 undocumented immigrants. These moves have made him a lot of enemies including, supposedly, the Mexican drug cartels who have offered a bounty for his head (or so the story goes).
From a distance Arizona can seem like a screwed up place, and the mostly white northern states are notorious for turning up their noses at white southerners who get labeled as bigots, racists and homophobes. As a southerner, I take deep offense of this perception which is generally untrue. Non Latino white people make up 58% of the population of Arizona while in Washington State it is 75%. Including the Native American populations and other ethnicities, Arizona is much more diverse, and as a border state the people are on the front-line bearing the burdens of federal policies such as the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) and the so called “Drug War.” This creates an unhealthy environment where Arizona is impotent at creating solutions which address the root causes, which is flawed federal policy, but must do something about it, which causes elected officials to act in ways that are repressive.
I'm not condoning this disgusting law in any way, but it makes sense that it would arise and it has little to do with the quality of their moral character. During the protests, the police showed well heeled restraint, partly because of the massive numbers of reporters present. Ultimately, no chemicals were used or rubber bullets fired. This was also to the credit of the organizers who peacefully mobilized, creating an environment where people could blockade the street and get arrested or cheer on the sidewalk with their kids securely. I got the feeling that in Arizona complicated politics exist which doesn't simply amount to blue and red folks toting their party platforms.
Politics are strange, and the politics of Arizona are totally bizarre. Jan Brewer is the current republican governor who signed the law into existence but Janet Napolitano was the democratic governor before her and is currently the Secretary of Homeland Security where she has lead the effort towards comprehensive immigration reform. The law SB1070 stinks of a political circus orchestrated by the right to frame immigration by gaining the offensive. Meanwhile the Obama administration has been totally mum on the issue after earlier promises to move forward on change.
The streets speak, and Latinos have been the overwhelming force to hit them in the past 5 years, blowing away Tea Party protesters, anti-war protesters, and anti-globalization activists combined. May Day's resurgence as a day of mass protest across the US has seen millions of mostly brown skinned folks waving American flags. It is a simple message: Latinos will not be ignored any longer and they want their human rights respected. Politicians, especially on the right, see Latinos as a threat to their mostly non-Latino white dominance over the government. By 2050 the US will be a plurality with non-Latino whites no longer being the majority. Democracy is a threat to the power elites, who are mostly white, male and wealthy. They will no longer be able to hide their differences from the majority.
As we were passing through LA, we heard the news that Federal Judge Susan Bolton had granted an injunction on the most controversial parts of the new law before it took effect. It took some of the wind out of the protests when we got there, you could tell the numbers were lower than what people had been hoping for. However, this was a well organized bunch. The hundreds who occupied the streets had plans for being arrested and support teams were set up to help. They had a banner drop off a crane that was a dramatic event, gaining a lot of press. People blockaded the front of the city jail and they had a concert in support next to the jail.
I got the response from one person that somehow you always hear at these sort of events. In the local CVS, the man behind the counter blamed the protestors who did the banner drop for the police diverting traffic in the area, making him late to work. I imagine a future where that man is complaining about the traffic caused when Latinos are fighting the National Guard from putting them on trains and shipping them to concentration camps. I don't blame the guy. It is a scary world if you actually try and understand it, white guys in corporate wage slave jobs could benefit from some empathy.
Sheriff Joe came out and gave interviews as folks chanted insults at him. The local media was surprisingly sympathetic towards the protestors in their coverage but they stripped the sound from that clip when they showed it. It was generally good press and Sheriff Joe had to divert deputies away from doing raids to engage protestors downtown. The gears in the machine were slowed for one day, showing some of what was possible when people engaged in direct action.
This is not over. Arizona has a bum deal with a bad sheriff providing a screwed up treatment of the symptoms rather than solutions. Traveling 3,000 miles in 6 days to protest every hair brained scheme of the right wing is not a solid way forward for progressives either. Somehow we must seize the offensive by supporting sanctuary cities and demanding equal job rights for all workers regardless of immigration status. We are a nation of immigrants, everyone is illegal, and we should remember that, as we strive for a just, equitable and sustainable world.
Comments
Photos and article by Media Island
The Black Car Project http://autovoid.blogspot.com
I am thankful that we have
I agree with you
We need more courageous people life sheriff Joe who will protect Americans and do the right thing.
I agree. The citizens of Arizona stood up for their rights.
These kids that traveled to Arizona really enjoy the freedoms that prior generations have fought for. The people of Arizona support this law and want the laws of this country upheld. My family immigrated here LEGALLY and me, my family and many other hispanics are offended by how other illegal's think it is there right to come here and not contribute.
its too bad
Why is it too bad? It is not
Sheriff Joe
Norm, you know I don't often throw around words like this, but Sheriff Joe is a POS fascist. The same kind that my grandfather's generation fought a world war against. We don't need to be electing dirtbags like this.
Bread & Roses
Phil- I am not really sure
One goes to jail
to be separated from the general population to both prevent them from being a threat to larger society and for them to do penitence for their crimes. It is dangerous and immoral to imagine jail should be putative in its self because down that road we are quickly de-humanizing criminals and ourselves.
A State may repeal one's political rights but no one ever forfeits their human rights.
Opinions are like.....
You have yours, I have mine. When you are sentenced, it is a punishment, for your crime. Jail, is punishment. Currently we try to "rehabilitate" our inmates, and taking a look at our recidivism rates, it's pretty easy to see that it doesn't work. The system is broken. Sheriff Joe is on the right track.
Upcoming Presentation.
We will be giving a presentation to the community on September 15th at Media Island from 7-9PM. There we will be showing some of the video and audio we took during the trip.
http://www.mediaisland.org
The Black Car Project http://autovoid.blogspot.com
Treatment
We gotta treat the causes of social problems. Treating the symptoms won't make the problems go away. It's a waste of resources.
Treat the causes and make the world a better place, for all people—and that means everyone (regardless of age, gender, skin-color, religion, nationality, sexual orientation, or any other characteristc!)
Peace is Possible!
What are the causes?
What causes our social problems? A lack of morality and ethical standards.
Advocacy of every sin known to man by government, the media, acadamia, and the courts.
We need to return to a society that values the human person as a creation of God rather than a commodity or useful only as a slave to the state.
Oh dear
I am an Evergreen Grad and I cannot recall any student or faculty member advocating for
Gluttony
Envy
Lust
Pride
Sloth
Wrath
Greed
These are the traits of the modern day American NeoCon.
You know...
If three words were dropped from your statement, I'd completely agree with you.
Our fundamental social problem is that our society is organized by the principle of self-interest (read: selfishness). This principle drives people to exploit others for personal profit, drives our government to use trade agreements to exploit poorer countries in the interest of American greed, and drives racist legislation in reaction to the harmful impacts of the trade agreements we impose. And, though there is no sin more contrary to basic Christian values, far too many people claiming the "Christian" faith hold up this sin as though Christ himself invented it as a virtue.
Our social problem is indeed a lack of morality and ethical standards. But the root of this problem is not so much liberal politics as it is the capitalist system that you seem to hold so dear.
Bread & Roses
Sheriff Arpaio is one of those symptoms
that I'd love to see treated at the election booth. He panders to the baser instincts of his frightened constituents as they cling to their slowly sinking demographic edge. It'll be a good day when he's gone.
Nice. Important.
but not hyper local.
Beg to differ...
...but 5 local activists venturing 3,000 miles roundtrip put together by a local non-profit dealing with issues that directly affect the well being of thousands of local residents is a hyper local issue. It might also be a national and international issue but that doesn't mean that it can't also be a hyper local issue as well. It is really important that national issues be made relevant to local people and when local people take part in national protests because the issues affect local people that is news and perfectly legitimate to be on Oly Blog. I really resent your sentiment. I imagine an article written by a local veteran about his or her experience in Iraq you would consider not hyper local either right?
The Black Car Project http://autovoid.blogspot.com
No, a political road trip is not hyperlocal news
Hyperlocal coverage on immigration is talking to local immigrants and undocumented workers about their experiences in Thurston County. Hyperlocal is reporting on the half dozen bodegas in the area. Hyperlocal is reporting on why Oly Parks and Rec cannot hire a single Mexican or Vietnamese for summertime temp landscaping. Hyperlocal is interviewing my Mexican immigrant sister-in-law. Hyperlocal is not traveling 1.500 miles to taunt a senile Maricopa County sheriff.
And yes, the war experiences of overseas soldiers are largely irrelevant to local issues unless those issues shape their actions locally, and then it is their actions locally, not what they did in Iraq or Japan, that are hyperlocal.
Kinda a lame attempt at branding me as a right winger. But I digress...
You disregard the group being local.
I don't want to brand anyone as anything. I think you are wrong about what is hyper local. Everyone in the van was from Olympia and it was put on by a local non-profit and we will be giving a presentation here about our trip and the law and how it affects us locally. Hyper local is all the things you said it was clearly, but it is also the thing I said it was. Think globally act locally. Well how can we think globally if we aren't going out there and getting that information? Getting that information and synthasizing it for your community is the job of some journalists that is equally as important as the journalists that examine our own community in depth. The one benefits the other and they both enrich our community. Now you can trust the analysis of journalists that aren't from your community and don't know your values, problems or morals and you can ignore the outside world and how it effects your community at great risk or you can have your community send journalists to go out and gather that information for you so that you can gain a better understanding of an issue from someone who comes from and can relate it back to your community. This is hyper local news just not the sort that people are used to.
The Black Car Project http://autovoid.blogspot.com
I'd rather read about Arizona Immigration Laws
from local Arizonians doing hyperlocal journalism than 5 Olympians barnstorming in for a few days and writing pretty much the same stuff I read on Daily Kos, Firelakedog, Open Left etc.
What is lacking in your original post is any discussion of how the machinations of the Arizona legislature has had any effect on anyone in Thurston County other than you and your buddies. You make no effort to relate it back to our community. None. Nada. Zero. Ziltch. Not a single word.
As I originally wrote, your account is interesting and the issue important but don't kid yourself your political road diary is in any meaningful way hyperlocal.
Lastly, in effect you say "Hyperlocal Journalism is what I say it is". Bit Orwellian doncha think?
Hyper-local is nice...
But these days, there's certainly a lot on OlyBlog that doesn't fall within a tight and tidy definition of that. More hyper-local stories of the sort you list would be great, Laurian; I'd love to read more... (Go get 'em!) But personally, I'm happy to have local people posting about interesting things they've gone off and done, wherever it was.
If the blog ever got to the point where there was too much stuff on it to deal with, we could worry about how to defend our borders against people sneaking across them with prohibited posts... :)
Best,
Thad
Best,
Thad
Support Arizona
I applaud the legislature and governor of Arizona for standing up for the American citizens and legal residents of Arizona since Obama refuses to do so.
They understand the consequences of millions of illegals (law-breakers) who destroy property, rape, steal, murder and bring in gangs and drugs.
That you would support criminals is despicable.
You wouldn't be so crude if this weren't the internet.
I am despicable. Best choice I ever made in life was to be with the law breakers, millions and millions of them with millions more behind bars and millions more waking up now that there aren't any jobs. I'm with the law breakers who do all the things you say they do and a whole lot more you haven't. I'm with the law breakers who build communities, create equality, heal people, create art, make the best love, form the strongest families connected to their neighbors families and the land, grow their own food, create the laws, obey the laws, break the laws, steal and give, destroy property, prevent rape, form a strong civil society, and celebrate spirituality and their gods.
The Black Car Project http://autovoid.blogspot.com
who's buying
"bring in gangs and drugs"...yeah right. Who is buying? Americans.
Chad, google ms-13. Not sure
Immigrants, Pilgrims or Conquestedors?