Screening Embryos for Blindness / Deafness

Navigation

User login

Online users

Peter Alden Stroble
JMK
benny
levi clayton
Guglielmo
oldtimeydave
IFerguson

Support OlyBlog

OlyBlog is run by volunteers who care about Olympia. If you like what we're doing, make a donation:

OlyBlog is powered by:

Who's new

Josopler
jasonla
Jododp
Jfodfie
GregDiablo

Screening Embryos for Blindness / Deafness

Submitted by Robert Whitlock on Wed, 03/12/2008 - 7:00am.

The BBC WHYS program's Ros Atkins is asking what constitutes a disability. Do blindness or deafness constitute a disability? Whether or not you believe that that blindness and deafness are disabling, should embryos be selected and rejected based on the likelihood that the resultant human being would be deaf or blind?

Think about Helen Keller, for example. She led an awesome and amazing life. And there are a lot of people who are deaf and blind who do amazing things.

Also, I have heard that the other senses of people who are deaf or blind kick in to compensate for the lack.

Selecting embryos based on deafness or blindness: are deafness and blindness disabilities?

[go to original]

by Ros Atkins

This started with an interview on one of the BBC’s most popular news show, The Today Programme, and concerned a deaf couple who were trying to have a child using IVF. The husband argued that embryos which may become deaf should not be screened out. He wants all embryos to be treated equally because he doesn’t view being deaf as a disability. Do you?

Robert Whitlock's blog
Login or register to post comments

from Democracy Now!David

Submitted by Robert Whitlock on Thu, 03/13/2008 - 1:02pm.

from Democracy Now!

David Paterson to Become First African American Gov in NY History, First Blind Gov in US History On Monday, New York Lieutenant Governor David Paterson will be sworn in to replace Eliot Spitzer as the state’s chief executive. Paterson will become New York’s first African American governor and the first blind governor in the nation’s history. We speak with Harlem journalist Herb Boyd, who has covered Paterson for years; New York State Senator Liz Krueger, who worked closely with David Paterson during his time in the New York Senate; and Carl Augusto, the president of the American Foundation for the Blind. [includes rush transcript]

Aldo Leopold: "We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect."

And then what?

Submitted by security_six on Thu, 03/13/2008 - 7:47pm.

Kill the undesirable emybros? I see no reason to screen them, you roll the dice, you take your chance. If you don't get what you want out of a kid, tough. Get fixed. You rolled, you lost. I believe people should reproduce to replace themselves. Two people, two kids. Can't have any? Tough. Adopt. Nature didn't want you to have any then. If I sound harsh, sorry, this is something I feel strongly about.

"MORBO SAYS STONE TO FLESH DOES NOT WORK THAT WAY."

You are harsh, but you are

Submitted by Merwyn Haskett on Fri, 03/14/2008 - 8:31am.

You are harsh, but you are also correct.

I speak as one-half of a couple where health and medicine dictates we adopt when we're ready for kids.

I don't think there should be any reason to destroy embryos.

Your views are not particularly harsh or unusual

Submitted by Guglielmo on Fri, 03/14/2008 - 8:57am.

but your presentation is rather bitter, which makes your opinion only seem harsh. You could use the same tone to describe a rather harsh split pea soup recipe. "Don't like ham? Tough. Get a substitute..."

Something I feel strongly on

Submitted by security_six on Fri, 03/14/2008 - 10:43am.

I see people with herds of kids, or what really gets me, people who get fertility treatment and then have a small litter of children... it's weird. I have no great reason to feel angry over this, but it is something I feel strongly on. I personally have made the decision not to reproduce, my own small contribution to overpopulation.

“How many more times are we going to cower under tables and chairs, whimpering like mindless dogs, thinking that someone else has the responsibility to save and protect us?” -Ted Nugent

OlyBlog.net

OlyBlog is devoted to citizen journalism, including hyperlocal news and discussion specifically about Olympia, Washington. If you care about this community and are tired of corporate media, then this is the place for you.

If you'd like to contribute, please register for an account. Here is a list of local news beats that need to be covered. You can post your news as a personal blog entry, and it will be reviewed (and possibly edited) for promotion to the front page. Once you've established a record of responsible blogging, you can become an autonomous user. You can also send news via email. All members of OlyBlog agree to abide by our comment and fair use policies. If you are frustrated about something said in a comment thread, go here.

Now playing at: