User login

Who's online

There are currently 8 users and 53 guests online.

Online users

  • Ehver Green
  • The Original Yoda
  • jusbytheclown
  • Guglielmo
  • Phil Owen
  • Rick
  • Marcie
  • Chia

Support OlyBlog

OlyBlog is run by volunteers who care about Olympia. If you like what we're doing, make a donation:

OlyBlog is powered by:

Who's new

  • LongRider
  • non illegitimi ...
  • acreatureapart
  • eristalis
  • Hillguy

    Creative Commons License
 
Submitted by emmettoconnell on Tue, 11/27/2007 - 1:41pm.

I don't really want to get into a new discussion about the port protests, but I thought this was worth sharing.

For your reference, Robin L. "Buck" Torske lost in the 2005 primary for the seat on the council that Jeff Kingsbury now holds.

The entire meeting is available here to view and here to download.

»

Gee

I may have found just an ounce of respect for Laura Ware after seeing this.

Let me see if I can find any resepct for TJ... 

 

 

 

*still looking*

Nope!

»

The guy's a lightening rod for sure

But I respect his passionate commitment to ideals he wore on his sleeve for all of us to see. Nothing shady or squirrelly about the guy. I respect that in a politician.
»

Thanks for the video

Considering I'm not an Olympia citizen, therefore have very little to do with their politics, I've never had the pleasure to have listened to T.J. Johnson, nor met him.

Whether I agreed with his politics or not, I just listened to a well researched, well spoken, open politician that was not willing to take crap from the gallery (I thought his comment was right on).  Johnson was voted in by a majority of his peers and I doubt that he's changed on bit since that day.  He commits the cardinal sin of being too damned honest for most people.

I'm very familiar with that problem.

»

As an elected official you

As an elected official you usually do not respond to people in the gallery, it is your job to listen, not speak during public comments. I have a feeling if a politician that had opposite views of TJ had acted this way towards people he would be torched on this blog. It is a time to commend and thank him for his efforts and move on, not to excuse bad attitudes towards citizens who disagree with him. Civility in public discourse should be the standard for elected officials. What was deemed as "honesty" was just an intellectually dishonest way to counter someone that he disagreed with.
»

I disagree

I think politicians should face criticism from "the gallery" more often and be required to respond. I don't like the idea of politicians being an untouchable elite. Civility yes, but there should be at least some dialog.
»

Wilson...

First of all, he was responding to someone interupting him....not to someone who had the floor.  "Sit down and shut up" might have been the better reply.

How about keeping reality in the picture as opposed to changing the scenario or doing the ever famous "what if?".

As long as intellectual dishonesty is going to be the new subject, I suggest you watch the video for its content and not what you want its content to be.

»

Torched on olyblog

Wilson wrote "a politician that had opposite views of TJ had acted this way towards people he would be torched on this blog." Are you suggesting that TJ hasn't been torched on this blog?

Peace became pizza. -- Guglielmo

»

no need to watch the video,

no need to watch the video, I was listening live
»

There we go again though.

There we go again though. Instead of congratulating a man on a lot of hard work we defend bad behavior because we happen to agree with him. It takes away from his hard work and shuts minds when elected officials act this way.
»

Gotta Stop this War

If you have a better way to stop the war, please go ahead and demonstrate for me. Lead by example.

I believe that nonviolent, nonthreatening, direct action - constructive protest in the form of civil disobedience - is one of the best avenues that those without significant financial, media or legal resources have to stop an unjust, illegal, improper and unwelcome aggressive foreign occupation.

And these protests are sincerely an effort to protect our military personnel from the harm they are incurring as a result of the abuse and misuse of our military by prominent members of the Bush Administration.

»

Robert ~ I Ask Again

If protesting this war is so important to you, why not take your protest to Bush himself in Washington D.C.? What good do you think you're doing here? Bush isn't picking up the phone and saying, "those darn kids in Olympia, WA are acting up again, let's end the war & bring the troops home."

You, PMR and whoever else pals around with you would gain far more ground and respect if you took your anger, attitude, opinions and protests to the source instead of destroying your hometown in hopes of being noticed & heard.

»

Onry..I RESPECTFULLY beg the question....

What was DESTROYED??????

»

Well

Bank of America's windows for one. Trash bins belonging to others for another.
»

From what I saw...

The dumperster wasn't ruined.

As to windows being broken, does this paint a picture for ALL OF THE PEOPLE PROTESTING?

I'm thinking that one person could have broken windows.

Didn't that happen to a school in the past couple of days?  Were those three kids accused of DESTROYING their community?

The real issue here is the rhetoric game.

»

I Beg to Differ!

There were trash receptacles run over and crushed.

As for the windows, whether it was one or more who did it, yes, it paints a picture of all the people protesting.  If you were to go to an event as a representative of your organization and you got beligerant, destructive and broke out the windows, like it or not, some if not all will assume you represent the people of your organization. 

I think it's semantics, not rhetoric here!  3 kids vs. 300+ protesters is a huge difference!  How you define words & numbers is different than how I do but I still love you!  {mwah}

»

Maybe that's a bad assumption to make

Maybe assuming that the window-breakers are representative of the organization is a bad assumption to make. It turns out to be a very convenient one for people who want to discredit the entire peace movement, though, doesn't it?

Peace became pizza. -- Guglielmo

»

It's a bad assumption but

It's a bad assumption but unfortunately it's human nature. It's not limited to the public's opinion and attitude against the protesters. For example I recently read an old article about the 40 Days protesters, some of it almost seemed word-for-word like the Port protests; they came in claiming to be peaceful; one or two people not necessarily associated with them displayed pictures or called teenagers whores-in-training, and not only the 40 Days group but all Pro-Lifers in general were painted with the same broad brush.

Kind of how all police are lawless thugs; all Republicans are bigots; etc. I'm sure everyone can imagine examples based on race or creed without writing them down.

Please give me a second grace. Please give me a second face. I've fallen far down, the first time around, now I just sit on the ground in your way.
Nick Drake

»

Well, Janet beat me to the punch

But I'm not going to miss this opportunity to spar with you....love ya back, more...LOL

For the record.  I'm against the war, and against any violence or vandalism that happens when war is protested, therefore I obviously don't condone such actions. (Sorry, didn't see any trash bins run over...of course, I'm wondering who was driving).  To tar and feather an entire movement for the actions of a few doesn't cut it.  Otherwise, let's turn this around and say that ALL the protestors were aggressively handled by the police when doing nothing wrong - another video I witnessed.  Yes, friend, tempers were flaring on the part of police and yet I'm not going to paint with the same broad brush.

What has made this event beyond imagination is...well....IMAGINATION. 

»

Strykers

When a few of the stryker vehicles were turning left (east) on 4th off of Plum a few protesters decided to see the worth of a stryker vs. a dumpster by pushing it out in the middle of the road.  Guess who won?  Lots of misdemeanors here!

You might not paint the police with a broad brush but many others here have.

Listen, when 60 some people are arrested in a few short days it doesn't bode well for any movement.  Assumptions aside, the damage done may have only included a few select individuals but it certainly didn't help OlyPMR's good name.  Take a look.

»

60 people arrested???? Oh my!!!

How many were prosecuted?  How many are in jail today?

The rhetoric game wears on.

Now, if I understand correctly, protestors used a dumpster to block the street and military transport ran over it?

 

»

Watch the Council Meeting

The mayor has answered your questions.  Larry, as much as you want to classify it as rhetoric, it's not.  But you keep on labeling it any way you'd like.

You understand correctly.  Somehow it's the stryker's fault, I know.

»

You Forgot To Give Him

the link to watch it!    ;-)

Here ya go Lar!  hehehe!

»

Is there some reason I should want the City of Olympia's website

»

Yeah!

So you can scroll down to the bottom of that page & watch the video of the Nov. 20th meeting! Silly boy!
»

OK.....

Now....is that different from the links that Emmett originally posted?  Let's see....today is the 28th...thus we should all be talking about the same meeting.

Let's go back to Larry's post where Larry said he doesn't endorse violence or vandalism.  Then let's review what BOTH sides could have done to avoid ruining a dumpster.  Is the point getting through yet?

Again.....I repeat...the continual rain of rhetoric directed at protestors gets more and more inflamed as we go.  There is no question that a MINORITY of people took advantage of a situation and went wild.  Frankly, I often wonder if some of these people are paid to do such stupid things, just to make a movement look bad.  Oh my....now I'm off on a conspiracy theory...LOL.

Some people took advantage of the protest and did wrong things - FACT.  TJ Johnson isn't liked by all - FACT

Beyond that, it's all just push/pull.

Oh...least I be accused of partisanship - some anti-protest protestors were vulgar and tried to provoke violence in our community also - FACT.

»

The majority of those arrests

Were of women sitting peacefully in the street, chanting "we are non-violent" and "thank you for respecting us" and "thank you for not using pepper spray." The police, behaving like true protectors of the community this time, rather gently removed each one of them. Those arrests did not harm the movement.
»

I Swore

I was staying out of this argument the last time & I swear it now! It's over, in the past and TJ is history!  I'm moving on!
»

Oh, he's not history

that's for sure. He'll remain quite active in the community, unfettered by his role as councilman. Imagine him with rabbit ears and a drum.
»

Unfortunately

I'm sure you're right! We'll be reading about him and his antics until there's finally world peace!
»

Yep

Rabbit ears and drum and his usual costume of peace through violence or the guise of non-violence through breaking the law.  Hopefully the screw on the battery pack strips out.
»

You're opinion is not based on reality.

TJ Johnson has never said a word through any of this about violence, and has never acted violently. Just because you need somebody to hate, doesn't make you right. You sound really ignorant when you say things like that, because if you knew anything about Johnson, you wouldn't say things like that about him, unless you don't care about the truth and just need a scapegoat for the all of the emotions that you're going through that you can't seem to figure out through rational dialog.

Non-violent protests throughout history have always broken "laws of the land", and are a lot of times directed at those laws, so what's your point?

»

I've seen TJ in "action" three times

Two times I saw him acting as a intermediary between protesters and the police to negotiate agreements between the two sides that avoided violence. Once I saw him step calmly past a baracade at the Tacoma Port and into the waiting arms of the police for his negotiated arrest. Perhaps EG has seen TJ act or insite violence at other times and would like to share those experiences with us.
»

Onry, right in your post....

You did it!  You claim the actions of possibly one, are the actions of the total.  You compared three kids to three hundred, knowing full and well that 300 people didn't break windows!

Using this approach, we can say that the three "gents" that posed for Gug's suitable-for-framing picture were representative of every person that opposed the war protestors.  I'd hate to think that all "Conservatives" looked like refugees from "Deliverance"

»

Newsflash Rob

.....you aren't gonna stop it.
»

How are you being helpful at

How are you being helpful at all here Norm? How is saying that, again, adding to anybodies experience here? I know it gives you satisfaction, but it really doesn't help anything. Maybe you should send these comments as private messages in the future.
»

I'm not

It wasn't one of my better comments.

»

stop the war? I thought we

stop the war? I thought we were talking about how a civil servent acts towards his fellow community members during a public forum.
»

Wilson...

If you were there live......did someone doctor the video and change places between Johnson and the person from the gallery?  I watched the video and clearly Johnson had been speaking for quite some time prior to the rude interuption from Torske.

Maybe the reality of the situation is that Torske should be publically apologizing to Johnson for rudely interupting his turn to speak.

In think you brought up intellectual honesty.

»

I better be careful what I

I better be careful what I say though. Wouldn't want TJ to think that that I was engaging in "hate speech" because I disagree with him. I wonder what he would qulify his opinions on the president as?
»

Thanks for dodging my question

»

Because an unruly citizen

Because an unruly citizen interupts a public official does not make what TJ did right. There are rules in the gallery that address people like him. Why the defense? It is simple, behavior like that from someone we elected should not be excused. He was rudely interupted, so therefore he acted just as childish. One difference though, he was representing me, he is held to a higher standard that a doddering fool in the crowd. Again though, let's defend his faults on a night of celebration.
»

Yeah, the cops should have

Yeah, the cops should have tazed Torske and drug him out, right?
»

Now....

Johnson doesn't have the right to respond to an "unruly citizen".

This gets interesting.   It seems to me that recently some "unruly citizens" were pepper sprayed.

Maybe we are getting somewhere in the conversation now.

»

I said listening live...not

I said listening live...not there live.
»

Thanks for your service TJ,

Thanks for your service TJ, good try, we appreciate it despite our differences. There, duty done.
»

I applaud him

I couldn't hear what Mr. Torske had said, but interrupting someone in that fashion is pretty rude. I still won't miss him when he's gone though, I think his efforts on the council were too scattered by international politics.
»

Not the first time

This wasn't the first time that TJ resorted to playground antics - I suspect it won't be the last.

For all of TJ's positives his opinion and ideas are overshadowed by his attitude toward those who happen to disagree with him.  He represented a narrow view and I'm glad to see him finally gone. Bye TJ.

I was there in person and literally walked out to the lobby when he began to speak.  Mr. Torske should have been removed long before TJ began to speak.  But, there's no defense that will change my mind about a man who can tell a citizen to move if they don't like his politics.  There's no defense for responding in public like he did.

»

Well now...let's see....

With your line of thinking, EG, Mr. Ronald Regan is guilty of the same crime as Johnson - telling a constituent where the sun don't shine.  I think you'll find a certain Mr. Bush or two did the same.  I could go on, but it starts getting silly.

Let's face it, the press are constituents (citizens) and constantly get put in their place by elected officals.  When those incidents are recorded I think they are played back at Republican Rallies and Fundraisers.

You don't like Johnson's politics.  Unfortunately for you, you were part of the minority when Johnson was elected, and I'm not so sure that he wouldn't get re-elected if he chose to run.  From the results posted by Emmett, it appears that Torske supporters (loud, obnoxious, wingers.....I could come up with a few more labels if you please) don't amount to anything close to a majority of Olympia residents.  Three other candidates out polled him by a mile.

The best thing in this entire blog, was Emmett's post of that election result.  It reminds me that the most vocal of the Rigid Right are a substantial minority in this community.  Counterbalance that with a minority of "ultra left" and......viola' you've got a nice thick base of moderates, which is what I've always expected.

»

Off in the weeds

as usual.  We can only speculate if he'd win another elections so...

When did I say I agreed with Reagan or Bush or Bush?  You're really good at moving the subject to your agenda or what you want to talk about.  That's fine, but I'm not going to satisfy your need to argue.  The topic is the OLYMPIA CITY COUNCIL meeting and TJ JOHNSON/LAURA WARE.  Yes, I am YELLING.

I said it above and I'll say it again, Toske should have been thrown out long before Johnson began to speak.  He was being an ass.  The two women in the lobby who were hootin' and hollerin' should have been kicked out as well.  One of them, Ms. Wynkoop, was absolutely awful.

»

And my slant on the topic....

Is how one local politician can get tarred and feathered for speaking his mind, while another polician (of a different flavor, regardless of local) get's applauded.

Nothing in the weeds here, just demonstrating the constant flow of hypocrisy which seems to run the RIGHT (not yelling) way.

I chuckle when someone demonstrates that Johnson is not so unique in terms of his behavior towards agitators, and then the subject becomes "that's not the subject". 

Yes, I've moved the topic to my agenda which is "Why does TJ Johnson get blasted when he does what many other governmental officials have done?"

 EDIT:  By the way, in being "fair and balanced" I believe Bill Clinton got a bit caustic with a former constituent not long ago.  Of course, he is retired and just another citizen, but I don't want to give the appearance of partisanship.

Now...we are still talking OLYMPIA CITY COUNCIL and TJ JOHNSON....I'm not concerned about Ms. Ware.

»

useless process

I have found that these meetings are a waste of time.

I don't think TJ is well spoken,but then again I have been less than impressed with any of the muni-wonks I run into here in Oly-

Oly Cops should not be providing military escorts, the US DoD can "protect" this stuff better than local cops, who in my opinion are making themselves real enemies in our community...

I lost all of the meager respect I have for the "pigs" (police officers in olympia) in Olympia thru two things:

Night riding in Oly and getting hassled for just walking around taking pictures (state bike cops riding on the lawns and sidewalks in the dwntwn core p*ss me off also).

How the OPD has presented themselves during these "protests"

 

...as far as I know, it is just another way to bill Over-Time, and not mandatory that OPD do any of this-- pls correct me if I'm wrong-

 

»

Pigs?

Oh, come on. Criticize them all you want, but leave out the epithets please. It reflects on everyone here.
»

What G said

»

This is probably not worth

This is probably not worth it, but....yes they are required to uphold the law
»

Officers get plenty of OT

Officers get plenty of OT without standing around waiting to clear people off of a road. The officers and the GI's were the only one's around that did not want to be there.
»

The protesters don't want to

The protesters don't want to be there either. If there wasn't a stupid war going on, none of them would be there. It seems the protesters are working in the best interests of everyone involved. In fact, they're the only ones being proactive about it.
»

Wrong

Being vocal and disorderly and unlawful doesn't mean you care more than the next person.  All it means is you don't care how silly you look or how difficult you make it for the next person, including your neighbors, service members.

Yeah, I know, not everyone was disorderly and breaking the law.  Like a broken record, round and round.  Whoow, whoow [while twirling my finger in a cirlce].

»

Sounds like there are

two broken records playing here.
»

Let's go for three, shall we?

Let's go for three, shall we?
»

Superiority complex

I think many of these arguments visa vis the protests on these threads would amp down a little bit if there didn't seem to be such a superiority attitude displayed by said protesters.

Showing up at a protest, sitting in a road proves only that you're doing those things, not that you care more, not that what you're doing is effective, not that you're better/more informed, not that you're right, not that you are the only people who had rights.

There were people there (truckers, police, military) who were trying to do their jobs. There were people there who were simply trying to live their normal lives, driving by/thru, and go about their business. And there were people there trying to express their support for the troops. All of those people, ALL people, deserve to be treated with some semblance of respect.

Comments here have routinely badmouthed and stereotyped the police, the pro-troop folks AND the regular folks who were just passing by. The police are allegedly ALL violent thugs, the pro-troop folks allegedly ALL support endless war, the regular folks allegedly ALL are mindless consumers too ignorant or lazy to give a damn about important things and who somehow deserve to be inconvenienced.

That is simplistic (you're either with us or against us) bullshit and I'm really tired of seeing so much of it here spewed by so many seemingly well-read and intelligent people.

 

 

»

Sorry, but your characterization of my views

and the views of most others here regarding the police, pro-troopers, and regular folks is simplistic and incorrect. Not all cops are thugs, not all pro-troopers support endless war, and not all regular folks are mindless. However you managed to conclude that based on the preponderancce of posts here is beyond me.
»

I'd say he's dead on.

I'd say he's dead on.
»

Ok, we're done here.

Ok, we're done here. Probably were done a while ago, but on this specific thread, we're done done.
»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

OlyBlog.net

OlyBlog is devoted to citizen journalism, including hyperlocal news and discussion specifically about Olympia, Washington. If you care about this community and are tired of corporate media, then this is the place for you.

If you'd like to contribute, please register for an account. Here is a list of local news beats that need to be covered. You can post your news as a personal blog entry, and it will be reviewed (and possibly edited) for promotion to the front page. Once you've established a record of responsible blogging, you can become an autonomous user. You can also send news via email. All members of OlyBlog agree to abide by our comment and fair use policies. If you are frustrated about something said in a comment thread, go here.

Now playing at:

Get Firefox!


More Flickr photos tagged with "olympia" and "washington"

OlyBlog is a site for news and discussion about Olympia, Washington.
free hit counter